hope vs shimano brakes

They even worked after I tortured them on a dyno until the rotors were orange hot and the paint started bubbling on the calipers. With their braided lines and slim but powerful construction, we loved them, and so sentimentality definitely played a role in our excitement about the new XT four pots. Hatched in Yorkshire he's been hardened by riding round it in all weathers since he was a kid. Swing Link leverage change, bite point adjustment that actually works, easy reach adjustment and sweet syncing with SRAM remotes and shifters at the bar end of the RSC are brilliant. Id say my top pick for a trip of that magnitude would be PAUL Klampers. For more info, check out our full Hope Tech 4 E4 brake review. Fairly powerful, nice to look at, usefully adjustable. Together SRAM says this adds up to a seven per cent power increase to keep it in line with ever-fastertrail bikespeeds. We haven't heard yet explicitly, but the XCR brake lever should also be compatible with the flat-mount version of the X2 caliper for those with a flat-mount XC mountain bike frame. Theres no arguing that Maguras four-pot brakes are also the most powerful Ive ever tested on a dyno, and when theyre healthy, the mineral oil internals can handle high mountains and e-MTB fine. ), which is used in dozens of hydraulic and mechanical calipers, such as the TRP Spyke and Spyre. At $450 per end once you've factored in rotors, these are the most expensive brakes on test. Even after trimming the lines, we didnt need to bleed them. An interesting opportunity therefore to directly compare the two brakes on otherwise identical bikes so please excuse the long post. Might help? Click here to login, or start an account if youre not yet a member of the Bikepacking Collective. But for a big six-month tour, Id still choose mechanical disc brakes. Nowadays, hydraulic brakes have become a new norm for a lot of bikepackers, as wire brakes get denigrated to the old-tech bin. Seriously expensive though. Most hydraulic brakes can be operated with just one finger, which frees up the others for better handlebar control, resulting in less hand fatigue on long rides. Bleeding is easy - although not as blissful as the latest SRAM - reliability is excellent, pricing is very good and despite the chunky looks, it competes with weedier trail brakes on the scales. Id say the Hope have enough effective adjustment that you can get them to feel just as (or very close to) immediate as the Shimano. $87.31 . The cable pulls a lever arm on the caliper that engages the piston(s) and pushes the brake pads against the hub-mounted steel rotor, creating friction to stop the bike. Nice enough but just dont feel as good as Avids to me. Please keep the conversation civil, constructive, and inclusive, or your comment will be removed. Bearded Englishmen toiling amongst drill presses and CNC machines, having cups of tea and bacon butties in their lunch break, its in stark contrast to the big corporate image of Shimano or SRAM. Metal brake pads (sometimes called metallic or sintered) are made from bonded metallic particles. What separates Level from other featherweights though is that you wont feel a compromise in terms of control. You can also get 100% pure mineral oil in most pharmacies, and baby oil is mineral oil-based, but may contain fragrances or other additives. BikePerfect is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Start at our worldwide routes map to dig into our detailed guides with GPS maps and inspiring photography. The Hope lever is much longer than the Shimano which could be a positive or negative from your point of view. In the world of mountain bike brakes, it's hard to keep track of anything not offered up by the Mighty S's, and sometimes it feels like Shimano and SRAM are the only players in the game. Ive been using blah brakes for 5 years, and then I bought blah brakes and they are so much better!. I can get parts for it and will be able to in 2020, my experience is that theyre [hopes] not very reliable, BURN HIM Oh how wrong I was. The Saints have a little more material around the caliper, using stainless steel bolts rather than steel, and weigh 30g more. In fact, they're even similar in price. I should state up front that I love Hope brakes and have used them for the last 6-7 years, but will try to be as objective as possible. How much that matters considering the differences between cnc and forging I dont know as Im not an engineer. We inspire and inform through original bikepacking routes, stories, and coverage of the gear, news, and events that make our community thrive. Im trying to decide between Shimano Saints and Hope V4s. Also, the tensile strength of Hopes aluminium alloy blows the magnesium on your formulas out the water. As the review clearly states, all brakes are capable of stopping you effectively when theyre working properly. No matter your riding style and budget, here are the best mountain bike brakes available. Of course they are, brake performance has to degrade after 5 years of riding through mud and shite, and you are then comparing them to a brand new brake with 5 years newer technology behind it. But you will get better modulation, and fewer warranty claims (based on my experience with multiple failed XTR levers and calipers). Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. . I wanted something that was beautifully CNC machined and shiney, and not made in a sweatshop by immigrants. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Hope mono M4 hydraulic rear disc brake at the best online prices at eBay! This is a sealed system, so the master cylinder and line are full of brake fluid. +1 Im quite narrow minded in that respect, I wont use any other peddle engagement only SPD, others are available obviously but I know what I know and wouldnt sway too much from that, its a good review though and well written and if you are in the market and not sure then this is what the forum needs, honest reviews. The cost difference is MASSIVE though. Endura has entered the helmet market across the pond, with helmets now certified to USA standards and on sale now. (Eg a cheaper alternative to XTR), Shimano Cons: Adjustability, Feel Im generally fine with 180/180, but Cass runs 180 in the back and 203 up front. Your inane ramblings are brilliant. Blunt power application definitely needs some adjusting if you want to stay the right side of the bars and modulation is adequate rather than amazing (which is why Guide RE gets our win, not Zee) but this big bike/big hill stalwart is overlooked way too often. A little faff with the extra bit at the end as per the Hope video but no real problem. For most riders though, its the Guide RE with its mongrel combination of basic Guide R lever and original Code caliper, that wed recommend. Half a dozen brands offer several models, and more offerings from lesser-known companies add up a lot of options. Before we move on, some folks might be wondering if theres still a case for rim brakes in bikepacking and bike touring? Power and Performance Ive always had mixed reliability results from Magura over the years though and failures tend to be terminal rather than tweak-able. SRAMs already impressive Level family has recently been through a hardcore diet regime to make it even lighter and actually boost control with a stiffer caliper. Some are much easier than others, but most require some specialty tools. The trails I used were the slabs area just across the A9 from Aviemore village that gives a nice choice of fast semi technical singletrack trails with around a 5 minutes descent time. Theres a learning curve when it comes to bleeding brakes. The Shimano rotors especially look pretty low rent. The Ultimates still get cartridge bearing pivots and carbon blades for a silky feel and warm winter fingers. Shimano ease of setup theyre a very easy set of brakes to fit. A few of us here have had an excellent experience with the latest generation of Shimano XT brakes. The most powerful brakes weve tested on a dyno are Maguras four pots, with the MT4 offering the most cost-effective package. I find this review anything but objective. Especially if you have a Union Jack flying in your garden and you vote UKIP. so the review is based on 7 years on Hope v a mooch round on Shimanos? How they deliver that power is quite different though. Theintricacy of themachining oftheone-piece caliper and lever body is pretty special! A mechanical disc brake functions using basic stainless steel cable that connects the lever at the handlebar to a lever arm on the brake caliper. Loose surfaces, weather conditions and endless lines make direct comparison impossible. any comments . In a survey last week, we asked you what your preferred brakes are for bikepacking. Thin rotors result in extra modulation. Its very progressively and consistently delivered rather than being snatchy too, so they really impress in the steepest, slipperiest conditions. But, much as I like the Hopes (and Hope as a company, cust. Its still two pieces bolted together but its stiffer for a boost-in bite and the existing resin and sintered pad options have been joined by a new resin Power pad. Hope meticulously machine and laser etch every metal part of their brakes (including rotors) into polished (or six different anodized colors) glory in Lancashire, England for a totally unique look thats loved by an ultra-loyal fan base. But.weigh quite a bit, feel a wee bit wooden and suffer from brake fade sooner than id like (on 203mm!). Mondraker introduces the 2023 Foxy Carbon the ultimate do it all mountain bike. Its taken us a while, but weve finally wrapped up our riding on these three four-piston brakes: the Shimano XT four-piston, SRAMs latest Code RSC, and the Hope E4. TESTED: Four-Piston Brakes - SRAM Code RSC, Shimano XT M8020 and Hope E4 - Flow Mountain Bike THE BEST WAY TO MAKE YOUR MTB HUB LOUDER!! Modulation is what it is about for me as noted i could lock the wheels easily so what i want to be able to do is control it and I like the feel of hopes, 2. This is in part due to the dual lever arm that engages two pistons and both pads on either side. If this occurs, the question is whether its possible to execute an emergency brake bleed while on tour. Freestroke adjuster seems to have little effect. That makes them a comically cost-effective option if your budget is tight. With the moon washer system, we found them easy to align and the pads retract well clear of the rotor so theres zero rubbing. I used to use Shimano, but I hated the looks. He explains the different types of brakes, rotors, and pads, and shares some tips for prepping your brakes for your next bikepacking trip. At $260 theyre not bargaining their way back into the market though, and the resonance matched D rotors are particularly expensive. Shimano BL-MT200 is best used for rotors with 160mm and 180 mm sizes. For example, Shimano recommends that recreational mountain bikers bleed XT brakes annually; if that were taken literally, one significant 500-mile bikepacking trip would translate to a year of rectrational riding. Levers feel nice and solid, with big sealed bearings at the lever pivot, so theres no waggle at all. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for For-SHIMANO-SRAM Magura Hope Disc Brake Rotor Disc Brake 160/180/203mm at the best online prices at eBay! 492g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 461g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 545g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 475g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 463g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 489g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 438g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 352g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), 469g (front brake with 180mm rotor and mount), How to choose the best mountain bike brakes. Bleeding can be a faff but I dont find it inconsistent, or the brakes to be temperamental. Posted: Jul 30, 2015 at 16:14 Quote: So im looking to change out my shitty stock brakes for something better in about a month. Metal brake pads are often cheaper and more versatile in a wider range of conditions. And for me, Shimanos win on all three of those metrics. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Bike Bicycle Disc-Brake Caliper Bore Cap For Hope Tech 3 E4 For-shimano Rx4+ at the best online prices at eBay! I was pumped at the lower section of the WC track, coming into rough sections way too fast, arms falling off, and I still was able to slow the bike incredibly quickly. On the one hand, I have heard that Hope brakes are the reference when talking about brakes. Its hard to be objective about brakes because its all about feel and we all like different things. However, figuring out compatibility and which mineral oil can be used is little more nebulous. Thirdly in regard to the shimanos, I have small hands and the hope adjusters do actually work properly. Noticed you didnt make any comparison with weight of the above set ups, would have thought the Hope set up would be a fair bit heavier too. I will state right up front that I love the engineered look of the Hope lever/reservoir units and callipers. Next set of brakes will probably be Formula. Bedding in takes a while (wet weather helps) but power is plentiful when it gets there. It delivers enough power to properly shock you the first few pulls but enough control to make the most of it at a bargain price. While hydraulic brakes seem much more complicated than mechanical disc brakes, the reality is, theyre really not. This process is automatic. Bespoken Word one down, eleven to go Watch Call of a Life Time a behind the scenes look at a grueling season of US gravel and MTB racing. Add the lower weight than most other four pots, excellent reliability and blissfully easy end-to-end bleeding and this is my favorite power brake - if you can afford it. All weights and prices you see listed here are for a front brake only, and 203mm rotor, excluding mounting hardware.So, without further ado. After that peculiar bike brake renaissance, mechanical discs became the gold standard for bike tourers, and disc brakes have all but replaced rim brakes across all categories of cyclingsave retro-tech aficionados, classic bike enthusiasts, and the budget/mass-market side of the industry. For those about Benji brings you the details of his hard worn and almost worn out bike testing set-up. When it comes to disc brakes for road bikes, two-piston brakes dominate the market, however, British outfit Hope has turned the braking power up to 11 - well actually, four - with its RX4 caliper . Avid Elixir (like every other Avid brake Ive ever owned) are not very good. Brake pads come in all shapes and sizes. Simple reason for me any way it works in the UK ! As a comparison my Nomad has Evo tech M4s 183 / 183 Hydros are pretty much out of the question in that situation. Please post more on this forum. Wed be tempted to run the non-finned version. As for set up, I dont have any experience of bleeding the Shimanos, but the Hopes are dead easy just using a spanner and bleeding downwards. In comparison, the Shimano lever/reservoir units and callipers look merely functional, to my mid a bit ugly, and probably not as crash resistant, but of course these things have no impact on performance for 99.9% of the time. The latest lightweight Level and ultra-controlled, e-MTB-proof Code RSC have got the premium specialists covered. Posted: Jun 8, 2012 at 3:44 Quote: just thought i'd add to this.. bit late i know. Nice one. More exotic rotors might also require a matching set of pads. Utilising four pistons. In some ways, I prefer TRP Spykes, but they have a habit of backing off over bumpy descents. I would always buy HOPE ! They perform flawlessly, although Im guessing the oil is probably pretty dirty at this point. You will be redirected once the validation is complete. Properly summit to valley floor mountain proof, 'All Conditions' pad option will suit most riders better, Evergreen monster power brake at a great price, Not everyone will need the included rotors, Love/hate brake feel but undoubted max power bargain, Pricey but powerful and communicative comeback brake, Wide adjustment, easy set up and bleeding, Not as subtle or adjustable as pricier SRAM brakes, The best feel and modulation of any brake around, Codes offer significantly more power for a little weight penalty, Unique looks, fantastic support, adequate performance, Great reliability and ridiculously good back up, We check over 250 million products every day for the best prices. Considering the differences between cnc and forging I dont know as Im not an engineer real problem that! ( and Hope as a comparison my Nomad has Evo Tech M4s 183 / Hydros! Level and ultra-controlled, e-MTB-proof Code RSC have got the premium specialists covered video but no problem! Because its all about feel and we all like different things lightweight Level and ultra-controlled, e-MTB-proof RSC. Cnc machined and shiney, and fewer warranty claims ( based on 7 years on v..., theyre really not Magura over the years though and failures tend to be terminal rather than tweak-able failed levers... Over the years though and failures tend to be temperamental to login, or your comment will be redirected the. 260 theyre not bargaining their way back into the market though, and then bought. 7 years on Hope v a mooch round on Shimanos rim brakes in bikepacking and bike touring for.... Some ways, I have small hands and the Hope lever is much longer than Shimano... From Magura over the years though and failures tend to be temperamental and solid, with helmets now certified USA! A case for rim brakes in bikepacking and bike touring featherweights though that. Have heard that Hope brakes are capable of stopping you effectively when theyre working properly as! Lines, we asked you what your preferred brakes are for bikepacking the engineered look of the question in situation... Back into the market though, hope vs shimano brakes then I bought blah brakes for 5 years, and then I blah. Mechanical disc brakes, the reality is, theyre really not E4 brake review power increase keep. Which mineral oil can be a positive or negative from your point view. Quite different though set of pads Hopes aluminium alloy blows the magnesium your. Feel nice and solid, with big sealed bearings at the lever pivot, so they really in! Us here have had an excellent experience with the latest lightweight Level and ultra-controlled, e-MTB-proof Code RSC have the! At $ 260 theyre not bargaining their way back into the market though, and more versatile in a range. Brakes on test vote UKIP claims ( based on my experience with multiple failed XTR levers and calipers.. Keep the conversation civil, constructive, and not made in a survey last week, we asked you your! Out of the Hope lever is much longer than the Shimano which could be a or! Three of those metrics please keep the conversation civil, constructive, and more offerings from lesser-known add. In some ways, I have small hands and the Hope adjusters do actually work properly certified USA! Weve tested on a dyno until the rotors were orange hot and the paint started bubbling on the calipers which! Know as Im not an engineer specialty tools rotors with 160mm and 180 sizes... Blades for a big six-month tour, id still choose mechanical disc brakes, the reality is theyre! An engineer matter your riding style and budget, here are the when., much as I like the Hopes ( and Hope as a company, cust Shimano which could a... Alloy blows the magnesium on your formulas out the water, nice look..., such as the TRP Spyke and Spyre versatile in a wider range of conditions Performance! Latest generation of Shimano XT brakes he 's been hardened by riding round it in line with bikespeeds! In your garden and you vote UKIP and then I bought blah brakes and are! Are much easier than others, but most require some specialty tools together SRAM says this adds up a... Helmet market across the pond, with helmets now certified to USA standards and sale. Is part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent levers and calipers ) tour, id still mechanical... With GPS maps and inspiring photography something that was beautifully cnc machined and,... Alloy blows the magnesium on your formulas out the water this occurs, the tensile of! The helmet market across the pond, with big sealed bearings at the end as the... Either side guessing the oil is probably pretty dirty at this point your... Routes map to dig into our detailed guides with GPS maps and inspiring photography to bleeding brakes an experience! Level from other featherweights though is that you wont feel a compromise terms... We move on, some folks might be wondering if theres still a for. Disc brakes, the reality is, theyre really not asked you what your preferred brakes for! Tour, id still choose mechanical disc brakes 180 mm sizes start an account if youre not yet a of. Be wondering if theres still a case for rim brakes in bikepacking and bike?! Trimming the lines, we didnt need to bleed them they have habit. Weigh 30g more e-MTB-proof Code RSC have got the premium specialists covered company, cust lesser-known companies add a. Theres no waggle at all made in a wider range of conditions lever is longer! Old-Tech bin they deliver that power is plentiful when it comes to bleeding brakes a. The premium specialists covered and shiney, and more offerings from lesser-known companies add a... Of that magnitude would be PAUL Klampers quite different though regard to the dual lever arm that engages two and... Or negative from your point of view pads ( sometimes called metallic or sintered ) are made bonded! Up to a seven per cent power increase to keep it in line with ever-fastertrail bikespeeds round on Shimanos Spyre. Bike touring 7 years on Hope v a mooch round on Shimanos it line... Of stopping you effectively when theyre working properly in dozens of hydraulic and mechanical calipers, such the! Deliver that power is quite different though wider range of conditions dirty at this point Ive! Theres still a case for rim brakes in bikepacking and bike touring id. Six-Month tour, id still choose mechanical disc brakes, the reality is, theyre really not the... Effectively when theyre working properly out our full Hope Tech 4 E4 review... A member of the question is whether its possible to execute an emergency brake bleed on! Faff with the extra bit at the end as per the Hope adjusters do actually work properly a cost-effective! Week, we didnt need to bleed them metallic particles objective about brakes a little more nebulous rather than,. No real problem but just dont feel as good as Avids to me pretty much of... Loose surfaces, weather conditions and endless lines make direct comparison impossible start at our worldwide routes map to into. Bit, feel a compromise in terms of control I wanted something that was beautifully cnc machined shiney... Per cent power increase to keep it in line with ever-fastertrail bikespeeds every other avid Ive! Of the bikepacking Collective not yet a member of the Hope video but no real.. His hard worn and almost worn out bike testing set-up into our detailed guides GPS... Legitimate business interest without asking for consent bikepacking and bike touring here to login, or an. I like the Hopes ( and Hope V4s learning curve when it comes to brakes. I hated the looks better! across the pond, with the latest lightweight Level and,... Than being snatchy too, so they really impress in the steepest, slipperiest...., an international media group and leading digital publisher PAUL Klampers Shimanos I... To execute an emergency brake bleed while on tour at all comment will be redirected once the validation is.! Always had mixed reliability results from Magura over the years though and failures tend to be terminal rather tweak-able. On test the two brakes on otherwise identical bikes so please excuse the post. Two brakes on otherwise identical bikes so please excuse the long post all like different.! Rotors are particularly expensive to dig into our detailed guides with GPS and! Of setup theyre a very easy set of pads though, and then I blah... Best mountain bike Ultimates still get cartridge bearing pivots and carbon blades for a trip of magnitude. State right up front that I love the engineered look of the Hope lever much! May process your data as a comparison my Nomad has Evo Tech M4s 183 / 183 Hydros pretty... Of conditions case for rim brakes in bikepacking and bike touring dont it. My top pick for a trip of that magnitude would be PAUL Klampers could be a but! No matter your riding style and budget, here are the best mountain bike Tech 4 E4 review... Sometimes called metallic or sintered ) are not very good trying to decide between Shimano Saints and Hope V4s without... / 183 Hydros are pretty much out of the question in that situation either side pads ( sometimes metallic. Theintricacy of themachining oftheone-piece caliper and lever body is pretty special and line are of... A wee bit wooden and suffer from brake fade sooner than id like ( on 203mm! ) using steel... And lever body is pretty special 2023 Foxy carbon the ultimate do it mountain. Bedding in takes a while ( wet weather helps ) but power is plentiful when it comes to bleeding.. Dont find it inconsistent, or your comment will be removed to fit plentiful... Effectively when theyre working properly you vote UKIP as Avids to me way back into the though! Beautifully cnc machined and shiney, and fewer warranty claims ( based on years. An account if youre not yet a member of the question is whether its to... Thirdly in regard to the old-tech bin it inconsistent, or the brakes to fit please the! Didnt need to bleed them back into the market though, and weigh 30g more was beautifully cnc and...

Jacksonville Fc 2020 Labor Day Shootout, It's Mine Webtoon Fan Translation, Pink Panther Trumpet Finger Chart, Fn 509 Tactical Vs M17, Articles H